I know some of you will be in a hurry, so we recommend getting the Farberware Yosemite stovetop percolator.
Traditional coffee brewing methods seem to be making a bit of a comeback. Even if you’re an automatic pour over coffee lover, it’s still good to have something manual in your reserves.
We’ve done some digging to find the best stovetop percolator to help you figure out which one suits your needs the most.
These are the products we’re reviewing:
How Does A Stovetop Percolator Work?
A percolator relies on gravity and the process of convection. It’s a pretty simple method:
As the temperature of the water rises, it moves away from the heat source.
The bubbles are therefore pushed upwards through a hollow stem that sits in the middle of the pot, and rains over the top of the coffee basket that holds the ground coffee. The water passes through the coffee, extracting the flavour compounds, before falling back through into the bottom of the pot.
This happens over and over until your desired strength of coffee has been brewed and you remove it from the heat.
The brewing process can take between 7-10 minutes and so it’s quite a long extraction time. Therefore, you need to have quite a coarse coffee grind. Go too fine and you’ll over extract your coffee creating a very bitter taste. Go too coarse and you’ll have a weak brew.
Heres a video to walk you through how a percolator works:
The Famous Bitterness
Percolator coffee is renowned for making bitter coffee due to the fact it just keeps brewing until you take it off the heat. Although it’s easy to over extract your coffee with a percolator, you can still make a nice cuppa. It might just take some practice before you get it consistently perfect.
Because they do make slightly bitter brews, they have become quite unpopular, with people adopting other methods like Siphon coffee or Moka Pots.
However, if that bitterness in a coffee is your thing then you’ll love percolators. Plus, if you class yourself as a coffee lover, you can’t shy away from brewing methods because they have a bad rep. Try them all, you might be surprised and which ones you like.
At the end of the day, it’s all a matter of personal preference. I’d definitely recommend you to give stovetop percolators a try.
The Pros And Cons Of Stovetop Percolator Coffee
Having used many different types of brewing methods, from single serve coffee makers, to Moka Pots and percolators, I’ve found there are advantages and disadvantages of each.
I do prefer manual brewing methods to the new electronic, automatic brewing coffee machines. I think coffee tastes that little bit better once you’ve put a little effort in.
- Super straight forward. There’s no programming, no settings to change, nothing to plug in, simply load with water and coffee and place on the stove.
- There’s nothing to malfunction. With some of these new electronic coffee makers, they have some amazing features that are really cool and convenient. I’m not against them at all. However, there’s definitely more things that could go wrong and you need a source of electricity.
- They can be portable. You can take some percolators away on trips with you as they’re small and compact. Even if you go camping you can take it in your backpack and boil it over a campfire. There isn’t a better sight.
- There’s something about a traditional method that’s satisfying. Seeing a percolator or a Moka Pot sat on a stove, with fire as a heat source, has a strangely satisfying and comforting feel. I can’t quite put my finger on why, but the smells and sounds might have something to do with it. Certainly beats the whirring of an electric espresso maker, personally.
- You don’t get a lot of options. A percolator brews one type of coffee, and doesn’t leave you with a lot of room for choice. Unlike some of these electronic coffee makers that let you change the settings to fine tune your brew.
- Some cheaper, glass models can break easily. I guess this is like most things though. Often enough, you get what you pay for. So buy a cheap percolator and the build quality probably isn’t going to be up to scratch.
How To Store Coffee Correctly
If you’re using a percolator, you’re going to be using ground coffee instead of K Cups and coffee pods. This means you’ll have to know how to store your coffee so it doesn’t go dry and stale.
Storing your coffee in the right way is one big way to ensure a super flavourful and fresh brew every time.
Firstly, if you can, buy whole coffee beans and grind them up directly before you’re making a brew. Whether that be with a big automatic grinder or a manual one, it doesn’t matter. Your taste buds will thank you for grinding the beans up yourself.
Not only is this good for the flavours, but also for freshness. The minute your coffee beans are ground up, they’re exposing more surface area to the air. The moisture in the air will dry out your coffee beans and remove those delicious flavour compounds.
Also use an airtight container. Those jars with the rubber seal around the lid usually work really well. This will keep the moisture in the air from affecting the taste.
Keep the jars of coffee beans in a place that’s out of direct sunlight and sources of heat. Like a cupboard for example, or a shelf. You also don’t want to be placing them in fridges or freezers, as this will cause them to lose flavour too.
Best Stovetop Percolators – The Reviews
Now you have a bit of background info on percolator coffee, let’s dive into the reviews.
- 36oz capacity
- Super lightweight
- Ideal for camping
- Clear knob on lid to easily view colour of coffee
- Quite flimsy
- Not dishwasher safe
Firstly this is a fantastic stovetop percolator to take with you on a camping trip. It’s small, compact, and lightweight so it’ll easily fit into a backpack. As long as you sit it flat it’ll work on a campfire without a problem.
For a brewing method that’s renowned for making a bitter brew, you don’t get that with this percolator. The flavour it extracts out of the coffee is really good.
The price you pay for the Primula is great, it’s one of the cheaper stovetop percolators you’ll find on the market. As we said earlier, the amount you pay may reflect the quality of the build and this holds true. It’s not a bad build, but it’s not really strong and durable build either.
When cleaning it, don’t put it in the dishwasher as it’ll surely break. Give it a handwash in the sink.
Perfect for taking away on camping trips. Maybe I would keep it for just that, and have something more durable for my everyday use.
- 40oz capacity
- Small and compact
- BPA plastic free
- Dishwasher safe
- High quality Borosilicate glass
With this percolator being glass, you get to see the process of how the percolator works exactly which is quite fun. Not only this, but you can easily see how dark the coffee is becoming, so you know exactly when you need to take it off the heat.
The fact it’s dishwasher safe also means an easy clean up process. It’s especially great if you have a busy morning routine. Once you’re finished with it you can just pop it in the dishwasher and forget about it.
One thing I found is that sometimes unwanted ground coffee finds its way into your brew. Some percolators have filter holes small enough to stop this, but it’s an easy fix. Simply slide a paper filter into the coffee basket, piercing a hole in the middle so it fits over the stem. It seems to do the trick.
The glass and plastic parts are durable enough to last quite a while, and for the price you can’t complain.
- 9 cup capacity
- BPA plastic free
- Lightweight so idea for camping trips
- Wooden handle for heat free touch
- Dishwasher safe
- Glass knob on lid to view coffee
Firstly let’s talk about the design. It’s got a great finish to it, being made out of 100% stainless steel. The wooden handle works effectively at deflecting the heat, so it’s not too hot to touch. The clear window at the top is made out of glass, and not plastic, meaning it’s not going to discolour after use.
It feels like a durable build, not flimsy like it’s about to break. With it being so durable, it can take some knocks and bumps meaning it’s not going to suffer being in your backpack while camping.
It produces a really great flavoured coffee and doesn’t let any coffee grinds through into the brew. Not complaints about the quality of the coffee at all.
It heats up super quickly too. We all get a little impatient for our morning coffee so the fact it brings water to the boil quickly is awesome.
Great build, quality coffee and easy to clean.
- 8 or 12 cup capacity options
- Permanent filter basket so no need for filter paper
- Clear glass knob in the lid to see the colour of your coffee
- Dishwasher safe
- Really good build quality
With it being one of the more expensive stovetop coffee makers on the list, you’d expect it to be up there with the best, which it is. The build quality is strong and sturdy, and the coffee is brewed flavourful. Maybe the best percolator coffee I’ve tried. Maybe. It’s certainly up there.
From what I’ve found, if you have a problem with the Farberware, it’s most likely going to be from the glass knob on the lid breaking. The reports of this happening are few and far between however.
It’s really durable too. Many people have bought this to take away camping, or have been using it everyday for years without any flaws.
It’s the little details that sell it for me though. Like the larger base so it sits sturdy and doesn’t wobble on the hob. Plus the handle has been built so that even large hands can pick it up comfortably without getting burnt.
- 8 cup capacity
- Mirror polished stainless steel
- Dishwasher safe
- Permanent filter basket
- Really aesthetically pleasing
Finally we have the Cook N Home Percolator which is a strong contender for being the best. It has a beautiful design with the polished stainless steel, and the permanent filter basket works well at keeping the coffee ground out of your coffee.
The knob is plastic, so although it doesn’t look as good as glass, it’s not going to smash or break. Even if it does, you’re able to easily get a replacement for it.
This percolator is tailored to brew a range of different drinks, so if you take it camping you can brew your tea or boil water too. The material retains a lot of heat, keeping your brew warm, but also has a cool to touch handle.
A really well thought out product with a great finish.
Who thought there would be so much choice when it comes to traditional stovetop percolators. Whether you’re wanting one for your monthly camping trips, or to use on a daily basis, there’s your perfect percolator on this list.
If I had to pick, I’d go for the Farberware Yosemite. The build quality is high and durable, so I know it’s not going to break after a couple of uses and I won’t have to buy another one. Plus the quality of coffee is really flavourful too.
You’re going to need some coffee beans to go with your stovetop percolator, so check out or reviews to find your perfect match.
Which one did you decide to go for? Let us know in the comments!